The Perfect Thanksgiving Turkey

Cooking up the perfect Thanksgiving turkey is a bit of an art form. Some like it roasted, others deep-fried. But I belong to the group that firmly believes smoking is the best way to go – after the bird has had a nice, long soak in a salty brine (See also – Brown Sugar Brine Recipe).

This was the first turkey I’ve smoked on a pellet grill, so I ultimately ended up spatchcocking and splitting the bird in half, just to ensure an even cook on a new smoking device. In years past, I’ve put the whole bird into an electric box smoker and given it 10-12 hours of low-and-slow smoke. This method cut that cooking time in more than half. Both halves were cooked within five hours.

Seasoning Blend 1:

  • FRESH SAGE, ROSEMARY, & THYME (CHOPPED)
  • SALT
  • CHILI POWDER
  • GARLIC POWDER
  • PAPRIKA
  • GROUND CUMIN
  • BROWN SUGAR
  • GROUND FENNEL
  • GROUND SUMAC

Seasoning Blend 2:

  • FRESH SAGE, ROSEMARY, & THYME (CHOPPED)
  • SALT
  • GARLIC POWDER
  • PAPRIKA
  • NUTMEG
  • BROWN SUGAR

Instructions:

  1. Take turkey out of brine and pat dry with paper towels.
  2. Use a heavy knife or poultry shears to cut out the backbone.
  3. Once the backbone is removed, crack the breastbone, then flip the turkey over and lay it flat.
  4. Use a heavy knife to cut the bird in half, right along the breastbone.
  5. Next, season one half with one seasoning blend and use the other seasoning blend on the second half.
  6. Use your fingertips to loosen the turkey skin from the meat, and get the seasoning on the meat beneath the skin.
  7. Dust what’s leftover of the seasoning on top of the turkey skin, and rub it in.
  8. Next, let the turkey halves sit in the fridge until they are ready to hit the smoker.
  9. Preheat your smoker to 250 F.
  10. Place the turkey halves in the smoker using aluminum roasting pans.
  11. Smoke until you have an internal temperature of 165 F in the thickest part of the meat, away from the bone.
  12. For a crisper skin, ramp up the smoker temperature to 350 F for the last 15-20 minutes of the cook.
  13. Once the turkey halves reach temperature, taken them off the smoker and cover with foil.
  14. Let the turkey rest for 45 minutes to an hour before carving.

Leave a comment